Health Data Enthusiast’s Review of Four Hot Activity Tracker, Fitness Bands

Activity tracker, fitness bandGuest post by Lee Springer – Lee is Chief Innovation Officer of Health As We Age and has worked with top Fortune 500 companies to provide the easiest-to-use technological solutions for consumers.

We’re beginning to see them everywhere as they grow in popularity. Some of them look as if NASA had built them for the last Apollo mission while others fit in the sole of your shoe. Pedometers, activity trackers, WiFi scales, blood pressure cuffs, and other consumer health gadgets are becoming more and more popular in a world obsessed with data tracking. Companies are coming up with creative ways to bring your health data to you via smartphone, tablet, and other mobile health devices.

Health As We Age logoHealth As We Age, (HAWA) takes your health data, and aggregates all your different device data into one central location. This helps our doctors, nurses, dietitians, and other health specialists understand you on a daily basis. We can then assist your primary care physician (PCP) to understand who you are on a daily basis, thus eliminating waiting room traffic, health history paperwork, and other nuisances.

For quite some time Health As We Age has been testing out multiple types of Activity Trackers and Health Fitness Trackers. Today I’m going to focus on four different products to help you decide which one may be right for you. But first of all, what is an Activity Tracker and why use one?

Activity Trackers And Wearables

An Activity Tracker (a.k.a. Health Tracker, Fitness Tracker) helps us understand the activity levels in a person’s life. This could be the office geek, the busy housewife, the top athlete, the construction worker, the grocery bagger, and anyone who has an interest in understanding how much/little activity is happening in his average day. Over time you can understand where your activity levels were within the past week, month, and whether you need to set a goal, step it up a notch, or bag groceries at a faster pace.

HAWA provided me with a series of activity trackers so here are my results and reviews regarding

–  Nike+ GPS Watch
–  Nike+ Fuelband
–  Fitbit Flex
–  Misfit Shine

Nike+ GPS Watch

It’s a bit unfair for me to compare the Nike+ GPS Sportwatch with the other three as this device is made to track running data only, and not daily activity. However, with its built in GPS and ability to count steps and measure heart rate, you can expect to get the most accurate data with this device. So I’ll be using the Nike+ GPS Watch as a benchmark to see which activity tracker most accurately tracks planned physical activities.

Nike+ Fuelband

Nike is, of course, a big name brand for basically any kind of sportswear and so it’s not surprising that their activity tracker has quite a following. However I was surprised to find the data captured by the Nike+ Fuelband was not very accurate. This to me was quite upsetting as I have fallen in love with my Nike Running App, Nike+ GPS Watch, etc. and was thrilled to bring in daily activity tracking into my planned workout activity. The good thing is that Nike does a great job displaying results, bringing some friendly competition to other members of the Nike+ Community, and reporting your data.

  • Accuracy: 4/10
  • Look, Feel: 5/10
  • Durability: 6/10
  • Data Reported: 5/10

Fitbit Flex

The Fitbit Flex is a well-rounded activity tracker that tells you much more than calories burned and distance walked. It calculates for you your calories in versus calories, monitors your sleep quality, and with the Aria scale, you can get an update anytime on your weight, BMI, and body fat percentage. It might be a bit of data overload, but for someone who’s looking for an all-in-one health tracking solution, the Fitbit is a great fit!

  • Accuracy: 9/10
  • Look, Feel: 8/10
  • Durability: 5/10
  • Data Reported: 9/10

Misfit Shine

The sexiest of the activity trackers, the Misfit Shine brings glamour to healthcare technology. It’s only been out on the market for a few weeks, so I’m sure there will be lessons to learn and bugs to fix. But all in all, the Shine did an excellent job reporting data. It was also a great conversation starter at an awkward block party BBQ. However I was sad when my rubber clasp got punctured with a very tiny hole, which days later became a much bigger hole. Fortunately, when I reported the issue to Misift, they had no problem sending me a new clasp right away.

All in all the Shine is a great tool with simplicity written all over it. I’m very excited to see what the Misfit team will come out with in the near future.

  • Accuracy: 9/10
  • Look, Feel: 10/10
  • Durability: 4/10
  • Data Reported: 8/10

Which is the best Fitness Tracker of all?

wearable fitness tracker

Left to right: Nike GPS Watch, Misfit Shine, Fitbit Flex, Nike Fuelband

It depends what you’re looking for. I’m a big fan of seeing my daily progress in charts, graphs, and stats. All three devices do a great job bringing me weekly averages, however not all of them capture daily data as accurately. If you’re like me and are in love with collecting as much data as possible, I would suggest investing in the Fitbit Flex. If you like the latest slick gadget and enjoy being a beta user, I would highly suggest the Shine instead. Misfit Wearables did a great job launching the Shine into the market and will probably be sticking around for sometime. Here is also CNET reviewer Danny Sullivan’s exploration of four Activity Trackers, including two other trackers: the Jawbone Up and BodyMedia Fit Link. In any case, it’s exciting to see the evolution of these tools being used within Healthcare!

Appendix: My Fitness Tracker Data Comparison Charts

To give you a more accurate understanding of the data in the charts, here is a sketch of what one of my days was like:  I woke up to get my two kids up, fed, and out the door to church, followed by an afternoon picnic, a 45 min run, a grocery shopping spree, dinner, baths, and bed for the kids, then finished off the day by cooking dinner with my wife for ourselves. I expected a lot of activity to report on.


Activity Tracker data fitness tracker data fitness tracker data activity tracker daily data


Activity Tracker data


fitness tracker data


activity tracker daily data

Comments ( 5 )
  • anne
    Steve White says:

    I’ve got a Fitbit Flex and I love it.

  • anne
    Maria says:

    I am using a fitbit flex, which seems to work fine. however, I also have a garmin forerunner gps watch and recently wore both on a run, on several ocassions. I am a bit perplexed at the discrepancy between the readings. the fitbit always measures more than a mile less that what the garmin registers. do you know which is more accurate?

  • anne
    AReed says:

    Maria- this also happened to me! I ran 2 miles using the GPS tracking on my Nike+ phone app, but my Fitbit Force only registered that I had ran 1.2 miles. Can’t figure it out reading on the internet.

  • anne
    compare fitness trackers says:

    Thanks for your comment about your experiment.
    this article is a really help us, i will also tell to my friend about your business….!!

  • anne
    Fitness Tracker news says:

    I have been using a fitness tracker news from i have loved it. Its easy to use and efficient for what i need. together with my meal plan it have seen great results. there are a lot of negative posts about Fitness Tracker news. and while i agree that some get one thinking that it will fix the inactivity problem others have,Thanks for the post.

The comments are now closed.

%d bloggers like this: